
NWI Property Tax Proration: What Sellers Owe at Closing
How much property tax will you credit the buyer when you sell a Northwest Indiana home?
Indiana property taxes are paid one year behind, so when you sell a home in Lake, Porter, or La Porte County, you typically credit the buyer for every day of the current year you owned it, plus any prior-year tax that hasn't been paid yet. On a December closing, that credit can equal close to a full year of taxes. Your title company calculates it from the most recent tax bill, and it comes straight out of your proceeds on the settlement statement.
By the Constellation Home Sales Team | November 21, 2026
Here's the moment most Northwest Indiana sellers get surprised. You've paid your May and November installments on time, every year. Then the settlement statement shows a line item for thousands of dollars in "county taxes" credited to the buyer.
Nothing went wrong. That's how Indiana works. Once you understand the arrears system, you can plan for it, price around it, and pick a closing date with your eyes open.
We walk sellers through this on almost every Lake and Porter County listing appointment right now, because it's one of the biggest numbers on a seller net sheet that nobody mentions until the end.
Why Indiana Sellers Pay Property Taxes a Year Behind
Indiana assesses property as of January 1, then bills that year's tax the following spring. The 2026 tax year is billed in 2027. That's why you'll hear county offices describe a bill as "2026 pay 2027."
Bills are paid in two installments. According to the Indiana Department of Local Government Finance, the 2026 due dates were May 11, 2026 and November 10, 2026. Those payments covered the 2025 tax year, not 2026.
So if you close on your Crown Point, Valparaiso, or Munster home this December, here's where you stand:
2025 taxes (paid in 2026): Already paid, assuming both installments went in on time.
2026 taxes (billed in 2027): Not billed yet. You owned the home for nearly all of 2026, so you owe that share.
The buyer's role: The buyer will pay the 2026 bill when it arrives in spring 2027, so you credit them for your portion at closing.
Most Indiana purchase agreements spell this out: the seller pays prorated taxes through the day of closing, including any unpaid prior-year taxes. Your title company figures the exact amount and handles it on the closing statement.
What happens if an installment is late
If the November 10 installment wasn't paid, the title company will collect it from your proceeds at closing, along with any penalty. The DLGF lists the penalty as 5 percent of the unpaid tax if paid within 30 days of the due date, rising to 10 percent after that. If you're unsure whether a payment posted, check with the county treasurer before you list.
How the Proration Is Calculated (With Real Numbers)
Because the current year's bill doesn't exist yet at closing, title companies use the most recent known tax bill as the estimate. The math is simple once you see it.
Say your Schererville home's annual property tax is $4,800. That's roughly $13.15 per day.
Close on December 18, 2026: You owned the home 352 days of 2026. Your credit to the buyer is about $4,629.
Close on March 19, 2027: The full 2026 bill is still unbilled, so you owe all $4,800 of it, plus 78 days of 2027, about $1,026. Your credit is roughly $5,826.
Those figures are illustrations. How the closing day itself is counted, and which bill is used as the estimate, depend on your purchase agreement and your title company's practice. Confirm the exact method with your title company.
Notice what happens when you wait. The credit doesn't reset on January 1. It keeps growing every day until the next bill is paid. That's a real factor when you're deciding between listing now and waiting for spring, which we break down in our post on whether to list this winter or wait for spring in Northwest Indiana.
Why your homestead status changes the number
Indiana's constitutional tax caps limit a homestead's bill to 1 percent of its gross assessed value, 2 percent for residential rentals, and 3 percent for most other property, before certain voter-approved levies. That means the same house can carry very different bills depending on how it's used.
This matters most in three situations we handle constantly:
Inherited homes: If the home passed to you and no longer carries a homestead deduction, the most recent bill may be much higher than what your parent paid. On a $9,600 annual bill, a December 18 closing means a credit of about $9,258.
Former rentals: A home taxed at the 2 percent cap prorates at that higher bill.
Recent buyers turning around to sell: If you never filed your homestead deduction, your bill may be higher than it should be. Ask the county auditor whether a filing still applies.
One more wrinkle for 2026: the 2025 property tax reform (Senate Enrolled Act 1) created a credit worth 10 percent of each homestead's bill, up to $300, for bills due in 2026 through 2028, as reported by the Indiana Capital Chronicle. Your most recent bill already reflects any credits and deductions you received, which is part of why the proration is an estimate. If you want the bigger picture, our guide to NWI property tax changes for buyers and sellers covers how the reform affects bills.
How to Plan for the Credit Before You List
The proration isn't a cost you can negotiate away the way you might negotiate a repair. It's built into the contract. You can still plan around it so it never catches you off guard.
Pull your most recent tax statement now. That's the number your title company will likely use.
Put the proration on your net sheet from day one. It belongs right next to commission, title fees, and payoff. Our breakdown of the cost to sell a house in Northwest Indiana shows where it fits.
Weigh your closing month. A buyer asking for a February or March close means a larger credit from you. That can be fine, as long as you see the number before you sign.
Read the tax clause in every offer. When you're comparing offers, the proration terms are identical in most contracts, so a higher price with a later closing date may net you less than it looks.
Know which form is which. At closing, the title company files the Sales Disclosure Form (State Form 46021) with the county auditor. That's a property-tax filing, separate from the Seller's Residential Real Estate Sales Disclosure about the home's condition. We explain both in Indiana's seller disclosure vs. Form 46021. The filing fee varies by county, so confirm the current fee with your title company.
Timing matters more than usual this season. The Indiana Association of REALTORS reported October 2026 statewide closed sales down 10 percent from a year earlier, with the median price steady at $270,000, and Freddie Mac's 30-year average rose to 7.28 percent the week of November 19. When buyers are scarcer, sellers tend to accept later closing dates to keep a deal together, and every extra week adds to the tax credit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Indiana home sellers pay property taxes a year behind?
Yes. Indiana taxes are billed and paid the year after the assessment year, so taxes paid in May and November 2026 covered 2025. When you sell, you typically credit the buyer for the current year's taxes through your closing date, because the buyer will pay that bill when it arrives.
How does the title company calculate property tax proration in Lake County?
Most title companies take the most recent known annual tax bill, divide it into a daily rate, and multiply it by the days you owned the home in the unbilled period. The amount appears as a credit to the buyer and a charge to you on the settlement statement. Your purchase agreement controls the exact method, so confirm it with your title company.
Will I owe more property tax at closing if I wait until spring to sell?
Usually, yes. If you close in early 2027, you'll likely owe the full unbilled 2026 tax plus the days you owned the home in 2027. The credit keeps growing until the next installment is paid.
What if I inherited the house and it has no homestead deduction?
The proration is based on the property's most recent bill, so a home without a homestead deduction can carry a much higher credit at closing. Check the latest statement and talk with the county auditor about the property's current deductions before you set your price.
Is the Sales Disclosure Form the same as the seller's disclosure?
No. The Sales Disclosure Form, State Form 46021, is a property-tax filing submitted to the county auditor at closing. The Seller's Residential Real Estate Sales Disclosure is a separate statement about the home's condition that the buyer receives before an offer is accepted.
The property tax proration is one of the largest numbers on a Northwest Indiana seller's settlement statement, and it's completely predictable once you know how Indiana's arrears system works. Seeing it early lets you choose your list price and closing date based on your real net, not a surprise at the closing table.
Want to know your exact credit before you list? Text or call 630-912-9129 with your address and the month you're hoping to close, and we'll pull your latest tax bill and show you precisely what will come out of your proceeds.
About the Constellation Home Sales Team
The Constellation Home Sales Team — Steve Roake and Kimberly Genovese — has closed more than 615 transactions worth over $113 million across Chicago's southwest suburbs and Northwest Indiana. Licensed since 2003 and operating under Keller Williams Preferred Realty, the team specializes in probate and estate sales, expired listings, negotiation, and divorce and life-transition sales, with a track record of selling homes at 101% of list price against a 97.7% MLS-wide average. Connect with the team at freedomgroupglobal.com or 630-912-9129.
